The new menace that came with Bt cotton Dr. Mae-Wan Ho
“In the Malwa belt of rural Punjab, mile after mile of Bt cotton fields are under attack by the mealy bug pest,” a news feature reported in 2007 [1]. “Bathinda, Muktsar, Faridkot and Ferozepur, Punjab’s four major cotton-growing districts, have been badly affected. The so-called “magic bullet” Bt cotton has turned into a bitter pill for farmers who were promised profits but who are now faced with huge losses.”
Bt cotton officially entered Punjab in 2005, but farmers began cultivating bootlegged varieties from Gujarat a year earlier. According to official statistics, around 60 percent of farmers in the state were growing Bt cotton by 2007, and almost 100 percent in the four cotton producing districts.
In contrast to Andhra Pradesh and elsewhere in India, Bt cotton in Punjab lived up to its promise of protecting against the American bollworm, and the number of sprays needed dropped from 30 to less than 5.
However, cotton is attacked by no less than 165 pests, and risks of resurgence of secondary pests are high.
In Andhra Pradesh, the number of attacks by aphids, thrips, jassids, etc. had risen since the introduction of Bt cotton in 2002. Tobacco leaf streak virus, tobacco caterpillars, etc have also emerged as new diseases and pests of Bt cotton. In 2007, reports of fungal root rot in Bt cotton were beginning to pour in from Warangal district in Andhra Pradesh.
Pesticides did not appear to be effective in controlling the mealy bug. Some farmers were uprooting the Bt cotton by hand and replacing it with paddy in order to recover some of their losses, but the price of rice was low.
“The writing on the wall is therefore quite clear for small farmers.” The new feature continued [1]. “Like in neighbouring Sangrur, the four cotton-growing districts of Punjab may soon begin reporting increasing numbers of farmer suicides.”
The central government Genetic Engineering Approval Committee had approved 135 varieties of Bt cotton by 2007, and had turned a blind eye to the plight of cotton farmers in Punjab and elsewhere. Not only had Bt cotton brought disaster in the form of the mealy bug, it had also affected yields of the subsequent crop, wheat. Farmers reported up to 30 percent drop in wheat productivity on land that had previously cultivated Bt cotton. Similar reports came from Andhra Pradesh, where Kisan Call Centre in Hyderabad received a number of complaints from farmers on declining yields of crops cultivated after Bt cotton.
According to Vyavsaya Panchangam, a farmers' almanac published by the Acharya N G Ranga Agriculture University in Hyderabad, Bt cotton used more fertiliser than non-Bt cotton. If adequate amounts of fertiliser were not applied, the subsequent crop received fewer nutrients. Furthermore, the Bt toxin also expresses itself in the root zone of the plant and can affect soil biodiversity and ecosystem function, as reported in a study by the Australian government. These factors might account for the lower yields of subsequent crops; although there had been little attention paid to the matter.
Hartej Singh, an organic farmer associated with the Kheti Virasat Mission, grew cotton intercropped with rows of pigeon pea, sorghum, maize, soybean, cluster bean, and so on, some of which were leguminous crops used as green manure. His cotton crop consisted of F-1378, an early-maturing American variety, and LD 327, a high-yielding desi (indigenous) variety resistant to Fusarium wilt. His yields were slightly lower than those of the Bt cotton in neighbouring fields.
But while the neighbouring fields were heavily infested by the mealy bug, Singh's cotton crop was completely unaffected. That was so for the 100-odd farmers of the Malwa belt growing organic non-Bt cotton as part of the Kheti Virasat Mission.
Intercropping with several different crops stopped pests from migrating to the next row of cotton, and as these crops were never sprayed with pesticide, predators like beetle larvae could be seen feeding on the mealy bug. Whenever the pest concentration went up, a combination of neem leaves and pods, along with Datura, etc, mixed with cow urine, was sprayed on the crop to keep the pest under control.
Bt cotton, genetically modified to make insecticidal protein(s) from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis, is held up as an example of a major ‘success’ of modern biotechnology in India, comparable to the Green Revolution decades earlier, according to the 2009 status report issued jointly by the Asia-Pacific Consortium on Agricultural Biotechnology and the Asia-Pacific Association of Agricultural Research Institutions [2]. First commercialized in 2002, Bt cotton spread rapidly, resulting in greatly increased productivity and reduced insecticide use. By 2009, production reached 49 million tonnes, bringing “considerable economic benefits…to farmers of all states.” Bt cotton hybrids now cover 7.6 million hectares, nearly 81 percent of India’s cotton growing land, and over 600 Bt hybrids have been released for commercial cultivation. More than 35 seed companies and public sector institutions are engaged in their development. A true-breeding variety has also been released by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research, so farmers can save their own seed.
The status report dismissed any link between Bt cotton and farmers’ suicides [2] (see [3] Farmer Suicides & Bt Cotton Nightmare Unfolding in India, SiS 45), but did not deny that secondary pests such as the mealy bug have emerged. The latter was attributed to the reduced spraying of pesticides after Bt cotton was introduced, which had kept those pests under control in the past. But findings on the ground and in the laboratory tell a different story.
Early in 2008, organic farmer Ram Kalaspurkar of Yavatmal, Maharashtra in India had sent us vivid photographic evidence of mealy bug infestations on demonstration plots of different seed companies in Vidarbha, all bearing the Bollgard label [4] (Deadly gift from Monsanto to India, SiS 38). He was convinced that the mealy bug entered Vidarbha cotton fields through Bt cotton seeds imported from the United States.
Kalaspurkar described how, when the cotton plants died at the end of the season, the mealy bug moved to nearby plants such as the Congress weed. By mid-June when farmers are ready to plant the new cotton crop or another crop, the bug would have multiplied enormously.
A year later, scientists at the Central Institute for Cotton Research (CICR) in Nagpur, India, corroborated Kalaspurkar’s findings, reporting widespread infestation of an exotic mealy bug species on Indian cotton [5].
The scientists conducted a survey at 47 locations in the nine cotton-growing states, and found only two mealy bug species infesting the cotton plants from all nine states: the solenopsis mealy bug, Penacoccus solenopsis, and the pink hibiscus mealy bug, Maconellicoccus hirsutus. However, P. solenopsis was the predominant species, comprising 95 percent of the samples examined. Furthermore, the scientists confirmed that P. solenopsis is a new exotic species to India originating in the US, where it was reported to damage cotton and other crops in 14 plant families.
Mealy bugs (Hemiptera: Pseudococcidae) are small sap-sucking Insects, and some species cause severe economic damage to a wide range of vegetables, horticultural and field crops. Infested plants can exhibit general symptoms of distorted and bushy shoots, crinkled and/or twisted bunchy leaves, and stunted plants that may dry completely.
Historically, mealy bugs were never considered major pests of cotton in India. There have been isolated reports of M. hirsutus on the native ‘desi’ species, Gossypium arboretum in Punjab and on the new world cotton Gossypium herbaceum in Gujarat. But no published evidence of mealy bugs on Gossypium hirsutum which currently occupies more than 80 percent of the cotton cultivated in the country.
The scientists surveyed 27 locations in central India with samples from 11 districts of Gujarat, 15 districts of Maharashtra and one district of Madhya Pradesh. The survey in south India included a total of seven districts, five from Andhra Pradesh, one from Karnataka and one from Tamil Nadu.
A total of 321 colonies of the mealy bug were examined under the microscope; and 304 were P. solenopsis (nearly 95 percent). P. solenopsis was the predominant species that infested cotton throughout the country and caused significant economic damage. The occurrence of M. hirsutus remained sporadic and rare.
P. solenopsis was described originally from the US, where it was widespread on ornamental and fruit crops. The first report of P. solenopsis infesting cultivated cotton and 29 other plant species of 13 families was published in 1991. Subsequently, the species was reported on other crops in Central America, the Caribbean, Ecuador, Argentina and Brazil, all probably introduced from the US.
During 2006, the mealy bug caused economic damage, reducing yields by up to 40-50 percent in infested fields in several parts of Gujarat [5]. At around the same time, mealy bug infestations were found in all the nine cotton-growing states: Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka. Severe economic damage was reported in 2007 in four districts of Punjab, two districts of Haryana, and low to moderate damage in parts of Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. Nearly 2 000 acres of cotton crop were destroyed by the mealy bug by mid-July, and over 100 acres of bug-infested Bt cotton was uprooted in Arike-Kalan village in Bathinda. By the end of the Kharif (autumn) season (June-October), the total damage in 2007 was estimated to range from US$400 000 to 500 000 in north India alone.
A report published by the Centre for Agro-Informatics Research in Pakistan in 2006 [6] also stated that the exotic mealy bug P. solenopsis had destroyed 0.2 million bales and 50 000 acres (out of the 8 million acres) of cotton area across Pakistan, especially in Punjab and Sindh provinces. It warned that the pest was still increasing, and could result in an epidemic in the cotton-growing areas if unchecked.
The mealy bug has become a major pest in almost all cotton growing states of India and Pakistan. Apart from yield losses, the cost of insecticide application has increased by US$250-375 per acre in both India and Pakistan [5].
Exotic pests with a wide host range such as the mealy bug can easily establish themselves, as they are missing their naturally occurring predators, parasitoids and pathogens. Moreover, the mealy bug has a waxy coating on its back that protects it from insecticides and other poisons that might kill it; it also has a high reproductive rate, an ability to hide in the soil, cracks and crevices of plants and the propensity to spread quickly through natural carriers such as plant products, wind, water, rain, birds, human beings and farm animals. Worse yet, it has the potential to infest other crops besides cotton.
The CICR scientists recommended [5] removing the preferred weed Parthenium hysterophorus on which the mealy bug multiplies and moves onto crop plants during the season. Planting border rows and strips (every 5-6 rows of cotton) of Pigeonpea Cajanus cajan (L.) Millsp., which does not support the growth and multiplication of P. solenopsis, would help control the pest. Timely detection and removal of infested plants along borders of crop will prevent further spread of the pest.
The CICR scientists warned against using the recommended highly eco-toxic insecticides, such as methyl parathion (classified by World Health Organization as Class 1a, extremely hazardous), monocroptophos, dichloryos, methomyl, triazophos and metasystox (Class 1b, highly hazardous).
The scientists stated that [5], “it is extremely important to avoid the usage of insecticides for the management of exotic pests, considering their propensity to survive, multiply and spread in the absence of native natural enemies.” They recommended introducing the ladybug beetle, Cryptolaemus montrouzieri (Mulsant), which they found to feed voraciously on P. solenopsis. These could be released on weeds and perennial trees prior to the cotton season, and during the season on infested cotton plants.
The scientists stressed that further studies are essential to detect predators and parasitoids that may be occurring naturally in India to strengthen eco-friendly sustainable mealy bug management. Otherwise it would be necessary to import their natural enemies from the US.
Their findings have been confirmed in a subsequent paper [7] by taxonomist Mohammed Hayat, who even isolated a parasitoid, Aenasius from the exotic mealy bug pest P. solenopsis.
When asked why it is so important to find out if the pest is an exotic species [8], CICR Acting Director and an award-winning cotton scientist Keshav Kranthi replied: “Because it has to be officially declared as an exotic pest to be able to come out with a pest management regimen for it.”
“The bug badly called for a control regimen to be put in place, especially against the observation that if sprayed with pesticides, it only grows due to the wax-like coating on its back.” Kranthi added.
The study by CICR team confirmed that the growth of the mealy bug menace can be attributed to the decimation of the parasitoids feeding on the pest [8]. This was why the year before, CICR issued the advice that no pesticides should be sprayed on the cotton crop, at least in the initial stages of crop growth, to let the parasitoids live on, as it is they that would naturally eliminate the bug.
Kranthi claimed that if left without pesticide spray, the mealy bug would get decimated by the parasitoid in a couple of years.
CICR has evolved a management package for controlling the mealy bug, which consists mainly of symptomatic control without spraying pesticides at early crop stage, continuous monitoring of infestation, destruction of cotton stalks after picking, and use of botanical and biological control formulations like neem seed kernel extract and biopesticides at different stages.
According to the press report [8], there was a sudden invasion of mealy bugs on Bt cotton in Gujarat in 2004, from which it spread to almost the entire country and even neighbouring Pakistan in the next two years, causing substantial economic damage in 2007 (see above).
It also brought a bad name to Bt cotton, as the mealy bug easily infested the transgenic variety, although it was not supposed to require pesticides.
Article first published 11/01/10
Got something to say about this page? Comment
There are 13 comments on this article so far. Add your comment above.
Surender Dalal Comment left 19th March 2010 14:02:43
There are 7 type of ladybugs, 5 type of bugs, 8 type of spiders, 6 type of flies, 13 types of wasps,2 type of chrysopas, 3 types of praying mantids, ground beetle,rove beetle and shoulder beetle present in cotton fields around Jind in Haryana.It means there are 47 type of predators present in our fields for control of this mealybug. There are three types of Fungal pathogens for mealybug menance subjected to conditions of high humidity & proper Temp. in this area.There are atleast three potential parasitoids for naturilly control of this tiny and timid mealy bug.Please come and see with your own eyes all this in the ground of war btween farmers and insects.donot try to fight this insect too only with if and but or with words like eradication, control & management etc. May i tell you this so called potential threat to cotton cultivation viz-a-viz Phenoccocus solenopsis is more vulnerable to predators as female of this insect has no wings & lays eggs in eggsac.More over this spp of mealybug is polypaghous and most prefered alternative host is congress grass.It means good chances for survival and multiplication for all the predators and parasitoids of this mealybug.If any doubt,do visit Nidana and Igrah villages of Distt Jind In Haryana and contact Ranbir Singh(09416517951) & Manbir(09991063510)
WP Themes Comment left 2nd February 2010 02:02:10
Good brief and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Thanks you as your information.
Surender Dalal Comment left 21st July 2010 17:05:12
Based on simple observations from farmers, may i speculate that it is not exotic mealybug which will be menance to cotton(BT & nonBt) but Red cotton bug and cotton dusky bugs will be a potential threat to cotton cultivation in India. for more details:
KNOW THY INSECTS and say NO TO INSECTICIDES!!
* http://www.chopatchaupal.blogspot.com/
* http://www.drdalaljind.blogspot.com/
* http://www.flickr.com/photos/dalalsure/
* http://www.kitsaksharta.blogspot.com/
* http://www.youtube.com/user/suredalal/
* http://apnakhetapnipathshala.blogspot.com/
Y. R. Palia Comment left 19th January 2010 00:12:51
Lady bird beetle would definitely go a long way in controlling mealy bugs. I have also observed birds like tailor birds feeding voraciously on mealy bugs. Creating an environment that attracts birds should in my opinion help. However they are no good as far as root mealy bugs are concerned.
Regards
Y. R. Palia.
Rory Short Comment left 12th January 2010 08:08:55
The linear exploitative paradigm, of which Bt cotton is a product, if it works does so only in the short term, long term it is a disaster.
c g hiremath Comment left 28th June 2010 23:11:43
If Mealy bug damage is so much then Why Farmers in Punjab Haryana are still growing Bt Hybrids.
Study and write in detail about the ill effects of Costly Chemical sprays used earlier to kill Bollworms. The residual effects of such chemicals are spoiling health of Children.
Dr.prakash dwivedi Comment left 2nd July 2010 19:07:44
I got a lot of information thanks a lot.which type of soil & climate is needed to culitvate & the best seeds for it crops from where is appreciated or recommanded.pl. advice.
preeti patil Comment left 19th January 2010 21:09:41
Have been running an organic terrace farm for nine years. However this year we lost so many of our plants cherries, guava, 4-5 varieties of Hibuscus, pomogranate to this mealy bug.
it has never happened before. in fact earleir just pruning away the affected part would enable plant to survive. but this time all new tender shoots have greater infestation. have tried neem, tobacco, chilly-garlic extract on these but it has not helped.
Reading this article is giving me shivers.....
What if the effects are migrating to urban areas too....This year we have been flooded with questions fromhome gardeners about the mealy bug infestation!
Is there a connection?
God save us!
Regards
VKV.RAVICHANDRAN Comment left 17th April 2010 02:02:31
Sir, I am farmer from T.Nadu growing cotton. The incidence of mealy bugs have been severe in both bt and non bt varities. I differ from the view that it is confined to bt cotton alone. Even the variety cotton grown organically is not spared. In the non bt cotton, farmers invariably spray chemicals to control bollworms which are ironically effective in eradicating non target insects like lady bird beetle, crysopa etc.In bt cotton field one can observe more number of such predators as we refrain from such sprays. The jassids,aphids mealy bugs and thrips are taken care of by these predators which are found in large numbers in bt cotton.
The sudden spurt in the mealy bug may be due to the continuos dry spell that prevail during cotton season which needs to be managed whether it is bt or non bt cotton.
Warm Regards,
VKV.RAVICHANDRAN,
FARMER
NANNILAM,T.NADU
09443683724, EMAIL vkvravi@gmail.com
MIHIR JHA Comment left 5th December 2011 20:08:16
I m searching about "Insect pest problem in Bt cotton past and present" if any one have any information related to this plz tell aur mail me. my mail id is mihirjhamj@gmail.com
abhijit Comment left 26th March 2012 22:10:55
Dear sir,
good article but only one objection,
use of word Bt specifically not necessary as mealy bug damages non bt also. it is an age old insect which was commanly observed on fruit crops like SITAFAL.
I found this article good, informative but partial with Bt technology. As that insect dont have to do any thing with Bt technology.
It is unscientific to say its association with Only Bt cotton
abraham Comment left 5th April 2012 18:06:59
The paper is infrmative and warns to take care of idiscriminate introduction of bt cotton. But I do not think that mealy bug problem is associated with bt cotton only. In my country Ethiopia we do not grow bt cotton, but recently the mealy bug is getting out of hand.Can other factors such as climate change, change of farming systems, heavy use of insecticides etc. be causes too.thanks
maewan ho Comment left 5th April 2012 21:09:54
The point about mealy bug and Bt cotton is that evidence points to the pest having been introduced via Bt cotton to India, and thereafter, it spread and ravaged other crops as well. Please read carefully.